Government guidance on whether nightclub owners should make their customers show Covid passports is “disingenuous and unclear”, a senior industry spokesman has told the BBC.
It suggests venues should ask for the NHS Covid pass or a negative test result when they reopen on 19 July.
But Michael Kill, who runs the Night Time Industries Association, told the BBC his members had asked him whether the policy was really voluntary.
One proprietor called it “unworkable”.
At present, organisers are not legally required to follow the guidance.
However, the government has also said it “reserves the right” to force venues to require people to show their Covid passport or proof of a negative Covid test in order to be allowed in.
Mr Kill said that although the policy was not mandatory at present, it could turn out that venues were “in the hands of local public health directors” who could force them to comply.
He said the government seemed to be “gauging the public narrative” before deciding how tough to be, adding that this was likely to cause “some level of chaos”.
Mr Kill accused the government of replacing the old clubland mantra of “Rave, sleep, repeat” with “Leak, listen, then release”.
The government declined to comment on Mr Kill’s remarks.
One proprietor, pub owner Julie Spensley, whose son Stephen also owns a bar and a nightclub in Middlesbrough, said it would take up to 10 times longer to admit revellers if they had to show Covid passports.
She said: “Unless it’s mandatory, we will not be introducing it.”
Speaking to the BBC’s Today programme, Mrs Spensley, who co-owns the Dickens Inn with her husband Tony, said the advice was “very unworkable for venues such as late bars and nightclubs”.
Her son, Stephen Spensley, owns the TS One bar and Spensley’s Emporium nightclub, also in Middlesbrough.
She said that the age group most likely to visit such places had not yet had the chance to become fully vaccinated.
“Nightclubs and late bars have queues outside and that’s the way they operate,” she said.
Staff already had to check customers’ ID to make sure they were old enough to be let in, so imposing further checks would not be practical, she added.
“We’ve had it tough for the last 16 months,” she said.
She stressed that she wanted people to stay safe, but questioned the wisdom of tighter restrictions on night-time venues when the government was easing the rules on social distancing and mask-wearing.
How can I get a vaccine passport?
People in England can do this by requesting an NHS Covid Pass via the NHS website or the NHS app.
Once logged in, an NHS Covid Pass can be requested. The system generates a QR code, which lasts for 28 days.
An NHS Covid Pass can be obtained two weeks after a second dose of the Covid vaccine, as long as both doses were given in England.
A pass can be requested if you’ve had a negative PCR test or lateral flow test result within the past 48 hours, which you have reported on the NHS website. These passes last 48 hours after the test result.
Alternatively, a pass can be given following a positive PCR test result within the last six months, and when self-isolating has finished. The pass lasts for 180 days after the test result.
People who have had both their jabs can also request an NHS Covid Pass letter by calling 119. This only shows vaccination status and has no expiry date.