Fortnite maker Epic Games has filed another lawsuit against computing giant Apple, this time in Australia, but the creators of the viral video game phenomenon aren’t asking for any money.
Instead, it wants a court to rule that Apple has to allow it to take payments from customers using its own systems rather than relying on the ones Apple mandates, for which the company also receives a 30 per cent commission.
In response, Apple has accused Epic of “reckless behaviour” that “made pawns of customers”, and said it looks “forward to making this clear to Australian courts”.
A lawsuit was lodged in the Federal Court on Monday, alleging Apple’s conduct in its App Store is a misuse of market power that restricts competition.
Epic claims Apple’s alleged conduct breaches Australian Consumer Law, but the company’s founder is adamant it’s more than just an argument over money between two massive corporations.
“It goes to the heart of whether consumers and creators can do business together directly on mobile platforms or are forced to use monopoly channels against wishes and interests,” Epic founder and CEO Tim Sweeney said.
He said Apple’s current business practices go against the spirit of its original products from when the company were “pioneers of the personal computer”.
“Anyone could write code, anyone could release software and users could install software from sources of their choosing. Today’s digital platforms must be similarly open to fair competition,” Mr Sweeney said.
At the moment, the App Store is the only way to get an app on your iPhone or iPad.
Fortnite was removed from Apple’s digital marketplace in August after Epic “defied the App Store monopoly” by adding a new way to pay that cut Apple out of the deal, in violation of the store’s policies.
Epic alleges those policies are so strict they “would have even blocked the World Wide Web if it had been invented after the iPhone”.
Apple said the policies are there to protect consumers and pointed to a judge’s description in a separate US lawsuit of Epic “clandestinely” adding the payment option, which it “intentionally omitted” when seeking Apple’s approval for the update that activated it.
“Our priorities have always been to provide customers with a safe and trusted place to download software and to apply the rules equally to all developers,” a statement from Apple reads.
The company added that Epic had been one of the most successful developers on the App Store, which allowed them to reach millions of iOS customers as it grew into a multi-billion dollar business. (In contrast Apple’s value is measured in trillions.)
Apple claims Epic knew what it was doing when it violated the policy that led to Fortnite being removed.
“Epic enabled a feature in its app which was not reviewed or approved by Apple, and they did so with the express intent of violating the App Store guidelines that apply equally to every developer and protect customers.”
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) chairman Rod Sims told news.com.au the case will be “fascinating” to watch.
Mr Sims said that “it’s good to see a case of this nature being brought” under the recently revised Section 46 of the Competition and Consumer Act – revisions “which were so heavily contested, which the business council so strongly opposed”.
The law was revised in 2017 and “now prohibits a firm with a substantial degree of market power from engaging in conduct that has the purpose, effect or likely effect of substantially lessening competition in a market” according to the consumer watchdog.
The ACCC is currently investigating app marketplaces, with a report due in March.
“We’ll follow this with great interest,” Mr Sims said.