After weeks of whispers, clandestine meetings with club legends, rumours of dressing-room discontent and general tittle-tattle, Ernesto Valverde became only the second manager in Barcelona’s history to be sacked mid-season when the club announced he was to be replaced by Quique Setien.Valverde had just witnessed Barcelona’s best performance of the season against Atletico Madrid in…

Guillem Balague's BBC Sport column

After weeks of whispers, clandestine conferences with membership legends, rumours of dressing-room discontent and identical outdated tittle-tattle, Ernesto Valverde turned most productive the 2d manager in Barcelona’s history to be sacked mid-season when the membership launched he became as soon as to get replaced by Quique Setien.

Valverde had lawful witnessed Barcelona’s most productive efficiency of the season in opposition to Atletico Madrid in the semi-finals of the Spanish Beautiful Cup (75 minutes of ideal football that ended up in defeat), had the membership high of La Liga, unbeaten in the league since 2 November and in the final 16 of the Champions League, having accomplished high of a neighborhood that integrated Borussia Dortmund and Inter Milan.

On the face of it, it is going to seem a bizarrely-timed resolution. But here’s Barcelona we’re speaking about.

Why this got here as a surprise to no-one – Valverde integrated

For some time now, the 55-three hundred and sixty five days-outdated Valverde has been spoken to by the movers and shakers at the membership over issues which possess been relating them relating to the team’s accomplish.

Many actually feel the side is going backwards, there are doubts being expressed in regards to the physical preparation of the gamers and the substitutions at some level of video games, rumours of a charged atmosphere in the dressing room are rife and there looks to be to be a lethargy, complacency and identical outdated malaise in regards to the location.

That is how it is defined from the membership, who desire pointing to the painful Champions League surrenders of the previous two seasons – in opposition to Roma and Liverpool – as proof Valverde may maybe no longer remove the team to the next stage.

There may be needless to claim one more side to the story. Valverde needed to initiate his time at the Nou Camp by managing the departure of Neymar.

“The Brazilian is about to leave,” considerable individual player Lionel Messi told him at some level of his first pre-season, the first news he had heard of what became as soon as going to be confirmed weeks later.

That season he ended up with a league and cup double. There became as soon as a 2d league title but Valverde may maybe most productive work with the cards he had been dealt.

He inherited a altering room whose fundamental characters are over 30, which is pale to doing things its win manner, that would no longer procure to be challenged, had signings that did no longer work (Philippe Coutinho attributable to of his personality, Ousmane Dembele attributable to of his physique, Arthur attributable to of his lack of focal level) and a md who kept sacking directors of football with out a obvious conception of the effect to head.

The surprise perchance is no longer any longer that it has took situation, but that is has taken goodbye to shut again to fruition.

So who became as soon as in competition for the job?

Valverde signed a contract extension unless 2021 in February, it looks to quash rumours about his impending departure.

There became as soon as ample evidence in situation even after the membership’s 3-0 victory over Liverpool – never tips the capitulation at Anfield that adopted rapidly after – to counsel there became as soon as a being concerned lack of dynamism, defensive structure, self-discipline and traditional vitality required to head toe to toe with a side be pleased Jurgen Klopp’s.

Despite the defeat in the cup closing in opposition to Valencia and the desire of many interior the membership to portion firm with the manager, each and every parties determined to head on one more season.

But as far again because the starting up of November, lawful after they had lost 3-1 to Levante, the membership approached extinct player Thierry Henry, most productive to be knowledgeable he had already signed a deal to be part of Montreal Affect. The Frenchman became as soon as told Valverde’s days had been numbered.

When they went to satisfy membership story Xavi final Friday in Qatar, the effect he’s manager of Al Sadd, they launched they had been going to seem Dembele, who also lawful took situation to be recovering from injure in the country.

Xavi has been to blame of Qatari side Al Sadd since May well unbiased

However the meeting took situation the day after the Spanish Beautiful Cup defeat by Atletico and, no topic the doubts for months about Valverde, there became as soon as a understand of political improvisation in regards to the bump into between Xavi and the membership (chief govt Oscar Grau and wearing director Eric Abidal).

It dropped at tips what took situation when the membership tried to operate the honest noises and understand as eager as they may maybe unbiased in re-signing Neymar from PSG with out actually doing so. Or wanting to operate so.

Xavi struggled with his resolution since the membership he loves approached him but he became as soon as no longer convinced himself of exactly what they wished.

Two things at final ended in him turning down the supply: the unstable enlighten at the membership with presidential elections in 2021 and the appearance into the scenario of a presidential candidate known as Victor Font, who has already declared that if he wins he would accomplish Xavi the unusual membership coach.

Many contemplate it is in most cases the opposite direction round, with Xavi deciding that unusual blood be pleased Font and a brand unusual regime shall be essential in the boardroom at the Nou Camp.

Additionally Xavi essential time to think. He believed next summer may maybe possess been his moment if Barcelona had given him total control over football issues, and he became as soon as planning to usher in high of us he trusts.

No longer to any extent further it looks; for now that ship has sailed, with the announcement from the membership that Setien has signed unless 2022. Any suspicions that ‘negotiations’ with the extinct Barcelona story had been nothing better than political expediency now seem likelier than ever to possess some truth to them.

Sooner than Setien’s signing one more extinct Barca player, the ex-Everton manager Ronald Koeman, also turned down their supply to remove the job unless the tip of the season. They generally also approached Mauricio Pochettino, no longer too prolonged ago sacked by Tottenham.

Ramon Planes – who pale to work at Pochettino’s extinct membership Espanyol and now may maybe be portion of Barcelona’s technical department – and membership president Josep Maria Bartomeu are each and every shut guests of Pochettino and in fixed contact.

For them to shut the available Argentine coach, it became as soon as potentially attributable to they conception they had half of a probability of him announcing sure.

Sadly, potentially attributable to of his prolonged history with Espanyol, Pochettino has a total again catalogue of statements he has made proclaiming why he would never remove the Barcelona job and the probability of him doing so will continuously be far-off.

That acknowledged, being viewed as a lawful candidate for this kind of prestigious appointment absolutely is no longer any longer actually going to operate him any injure in his quest to at final remove tag at unquestionably one of Europe’s high clubs, one thing he’ll positively accomplish at some time in the near future.

What’s going to Setien bring to the Barcelona table?

Setien (honest) had been Betis manager since 2017 and led them to sixth and 10th-situation finishes in La Liga

The effect Setien is a nice match is in his unquestioned zeal alongside coaches be pleased Pep Guardiola and Oscar Garcia, at point out at Celta Vigo, for the Johan Cruyff possession sport, considerable cherished and oft-perfected in the previous by Barcelona.

On taking the Betis job, Setien revealed in an interview with El Periodico that no topic his love for football he did no longer actually stamp it “unless I noticed the football of Johan Cruyff”.

“It became as soon as with coaches be pleased him when I began to get it,” he continued. “When to contact the ball, to pass, the spaces… here’s what I try to discuss to the gamers, to desire the ball and to trek as minute as that you are going to be in a effect to think of after it.”

He added he would possess had his minute finger slit again off to be given the probability to play for unquestionably one of Cruyff’s facets, “no longer attributable to I needed to be a Barcelona footballer, but fairly attributable to of the manner they conducted attributable to I may maybe gape lawful how considerable the footballers had been taking part in themselves”.

His groups in the lower leagues had been in most cases referred to because the Barcelona of those divisions. It takes a whereas to convince the gamers and heaps more the fans, and he never completely managed the viewers at Betis the effect, finally, he never actually had the depth of skills that he may maybe belief in to operate his plans to most accomplish.

Barcelona may maybe unbiased peaceful point out a more pleasant promote.

On the minus side he’s already 61 years outdated and lacks intensive high-flight ride with Betis being, unless now, by far the finest managerial job he has held. But he’s no longer any longer after a occupation, he lawful wants to search if he can get his near, so acquainted to the membership, to work.

But it’s no longer actually in the passing side of the sport the effect he may maybe potentially be let down but fairly in the work price of the gamers with out the ball, which is exactly the effect Valverde became as soon as frolicked to dry by some of his team.

This side has the understand and actually feel of the dressing room at the tip of the Frank Rijkaard generation, when I be unsleeping the likes of Xavi and Andres Iniesta telling me they had been losing their love for the sport. Drastic measures needed to be taken by Pep Guardiola in describe to head on to manufacture what he later did.

Will Setien possess the identical ardour and desire and be in a effect to operate what Valverde determined no longer to operate, namely switch the culture and dynamic of the dressing room? Will he be in a effect to operate what Guardiola did? This may maybe also be more easy acknowledged than achieved.

Guillem Balague is writing a recent column throughout the season and also showing every Thursday on BBC Radio 5 Stay’s Soccer Day-to-day podcast, when the level of interest will doubtless be on European football.

You can download the latest Soccer Day-to-day podcast here.

Share this:

About the author

NewsRoom Paperdabba